The House Versus the Senate

“Every year we send a lean thoroughbred race horse to the Senate in the form of a budget, and they send back a dairy cow. Full of milk and a whole lot of fat.”
—A wise House member

(A Battle Never Won By The House)

Nothing that you see in the above is original content from the LaPolitics team.

We didn’t write that headline. We didn’t come up with that kicker. And we have no idea who the anonymous legislator was who provided that quote about the budget transforming into a variety of bovine.

All of that copy was ripped, word for word, from the beginning of Chapter 10 in The Outhouse Report: Politics in the Louisiana Legislature (Quotable Quotes, Short Stories, and Thoughts on a Misunderstood System).

The book is a slice-of-life accounting of the Capitol from 1992 to 2002, which is when District Attorney Charles Riddle served in the House. Riddle, the book’s author, spent an entire chapter on the dynamics of this historic divide between chambers — yes, the same blood feud that’s slowly taking centerstage during the ongoing regular session.

In fact, you may have thought to yourself that the headline, kicker and quote were appropriate ways to summarize current events in Baton Rouge. Even if the content is roughly 25 years old.

For an overview that’s more up to date, here’s the lay of the land in our post-Riddle Legislature…

The House passed the 2018-2019 budget last week, but the Senate leadership is leaning against hearing the spending bill at all because its funding reductions are too severe. Senators also believe, rightly so, that a budget can be passed in the year’s second special session, which is expected to convene in mid- to late-May.

The special session will host tax debates that could soften the state’s $648 million shortfall. But some Republican representatives would prefer to wait even longer to convene again, just in case revenue projections continue to improve and sweeping tax increases aren't actually needed.

The resulting political environment — and it ain’t pretty — has led reps to label senators as obstructionists, and senators to accuse reps of not doing their jobs. These exchanges aren’t playing out behind closed doors, like they did during the Riddle era. They’re taking place over live microphones, in media reports and on social media.

It’s probably best that lawmakers will likely punt the budget to the special session. Given the time constraints of the regular session, in concert with the souring mood, the last thing the Capitol class needs is a contentious conference committee.

Just ask Riddle. Those conference committees can get a little weird, or, as the district attorney wrote in The Outhouse Report, they can also get a bit stinky: “You know what happens to a bill that goes to conference committee? It goes in looking like a cat, comes out barking like a dog and smelling like a skunk!”

So, who will win this round? Will it be the Senate (Riddle’s go-to pick) or will it be the House? Honestly, as long as we don’t all end up as losers, it really doesn’t matter.

SPONSORED: Congratulations to Bruce Greenstein and LHC Group!

Congratulations to Bruce Greenstein on this week’s announcement that he will return to Louisiana to lead innovation at LHC Group as Chief

THE LaPOLITICS REPORT: Picard, Politics & Ponies

In our latest podcast episode of The LaPolitics Report, Tyron Picard of The Picard Group drops in for a conversation about a bygone era in

CAPITOL GAINS: At Home with Clay

 “This is what America wants to see.” That was the promise from a beer-toting Congressman Clay Higgins in this episode of Capitol

SPONSORED: The 106th First Lady’s Luncheon

The Picard Group was honored to attend the 106th First Lady’s Luncheon, honoring The First Lady of the United States, Melania Trump. Held on


This story was originally published in LaPOLITICS Weekly on May 4, 2018. Wish you had read it then? Become a part of our elite community by


You could say legislators in Illinois really dropped the ball when they failed to pass an operating budget for their state prior to the 2016

POD: Politics & Drilling, According To Briggs

In this episode of The LaPolitics Report, we talk to Louisiana Oil and Gas Association President Gifford Briggs, who recently succeeded his

POD: I’m Sorry, Miss Jackson

Katrina Jackson, a state rep who’s running for senator, talks about her time leading the Black Caucus and working as a legislative staffer.

SPONSORED: Acadian Companies’ 2018 Medic & EMT Of The Year

On Thursday, May 3, Acadian Companies held their annual luncheon to honor Paramedic Jerret Dunlap and EMT Taylor Walden who were selected as

LOWDOWN: John Stefanski on Community

Crowley native and freshman Rep. John Stefanski is here to talk about community, both at home and online. John talks about the influence

SPONSORED: Congratulations!

Congratulations to LHC Group for being recognized as the 2018 Junior Achievement of Acadiana Large Company of the Year. On Tuesday, May 1,

SHELVING SCHEDLER: SOS now an open seat, special election coming

The field of maybe-candidates who were waiting on Secretary of State Tom Schedler’s exit were also quietly hoping for a special election,

Barras’ Ultimatum, JBE’s Tax Reduction & Talk Of A “Reasonable Compromise”

— Has Speaker Taylor Barras issued an ultimatum? Reporters and Gov. John Bel Edwards seem to think so. Journos put out the word via Twitter

ALFORD’S OPINION COLUMN: Democrats Still Finding Their Way At Capitol

Being a Democratic member of the Louisiana Legislature isn’t always unicorns, rainbows and lollipops. Sometimes it can get a little rough.

YOU’VE GOT MAIL: Lawmakers taking hits in their mailboxes

Rebuild Louisiana began sending out direct mail in legislative districts across the state last week in a “continual effort to educate the

Rabalais’ Political History: When a constitutional convention became a full-scale riot

By 1866, Louisiana had been devastated by the ravages of the Civil War. Almost 3,000 of the state’s citizens had been killed in the

Political Chatter

— Former Democratic Rep. Ledricka Thierry announced she is running for District Judge for the 27th Judicial District in the November 2020

Gamard’s Beltway Beat: Netanyahu & Gleason

Two things: — News broke yesterday that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is accusing Iran of lying about its nuclear aspirations,


— Tuesday 05/01: Gregory Todd Hilburn, Caitlin Berni and Rhett Davis — Wednesday 05/02: Elizabeth McKnight — Thursday 05/03: Former U.S.

WEEKLY: Amendment Bills Reach 6-Year Low

The number of proposed constitutional amendments introduced by state legislators during regular sessions has hit a six-year low, just as

WEEKLY: Dems Prep Party Candidates

In an effort to fill nearly 30 open seats on the Democratic State Central Committee and numerous other positions on parish executive

LOWDOWN: Helena Moreno on Effective Advocacy

Meet Helena Nancy Moreno. She’s the former state representative from House District 93, in the French Quarter. Helena was still in the

SPONSORED: CABL Drafting 2019 Agenda

For more than 50 years, the Council for A Better Louisiana (CABL) has been an advocate for positive change at the state level, focusing on

The House Versus the Senate

“Every year we send a lean thoroughbred race horse to the Senate in the form of a budget, and they send back a dairy cow. Full of milk and a

Stuff Jeremy Didn’t Know Yesterday Morning…

Between a book project on the 1973 constitutional convention, a series of history segments produced by LaPolitics, committee meetings and